The very, very, VERY best Ice-Cream Sandwiches EVER




No, seriously... These are the best Ice-Cream Sandwiches EVER. Every single piece of them is homemade (well, except the Oreos). 

I originally posted these in 2020 and the photos were definitely due for an update.  Also, while the original recipe from Half Baked Harvest is no churn, I definitely prefer churned ice cream.  It's softer and creamier.  And, a while back the kids bought me a cool old time style ice cream maker and I'll use just about any excuse to break it out.  




Nothing tastes better on a hot summer evening...I swear.  You can still go for the no-churn recipe here which is what we used the first time we made it.  Definitely use the cookie part, they're so soft and yummy.  Below, you'll see what we did for the ice cream layer.


Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

2 cups heavy whipping cream
2 cups whole milk 
3/4 cup sugar
1tbsp vanilla bean paste
1 tbsp good quality vanilla extract
1/4 cup malted milk powder
1/2 cup chopped chocolate sandwich cookies

Instructions
Line a 9x13 pan with parchment or wax paper and stick it in the freezer.  This is the perfect size for making the ice cream sandwiches.

Combine the first 6 ingredients (whipping cream through malted milk powder) in a blender and blend for about 30-60 seconds until everything is combined.  Place in the churning bowl and follow the instructions for your ice cream maker and churn.  Mine takes about 35-40 minutes to get to soft serve consistency.

Spread your churned ice cream into the prepared pan and cover with plastic wrap.  Freeze for at least 2 hours, to overnight.

Make the chocolate cookies from this recipe and when you're ready to assemble them, take the ice cream out and let rest for a couple of minutes.  Cut into 24 rectangles that match your cookies, assemble the sandwiches and wrap them up in parchment or wax paper and pop them back in the freezer.  Enjoy them and the summer!

0 comments